TryToolFit Get matched
Community platforms

What a paid community really costs: 19 platforms compared

We modelled a $10/month community on 19 platforms. At 200 members the bill runs from $16.58 to $925 a month, and the 10% fee tools land near the bottom.

Running a paid community costs between $16.58 and $925 a month at 200 paying members, depending on the platform. That is the spread across the 19 community platforms in our pricing data, for a community that charges $10 a month. The median platform takes about $145 a month, roughly 7% of what members pay. The finding that matters most is where the popular “start for $9” option lands: Skool’s Hobby plan, with its 10% sales fee, comes out 17th of 19 at 200 members.

The reason is simple. A platform charges you a monthly fee, a cut of every sale, or both. For a very small community the cut is cheaper. Somewhere between about 12 and 144 members, depending on which flat-fee platform you compare against, the monthly fee starts winning and never stops.

All pricing below comes from each platform’s listed plans; verify current pricing on the vendor’s site before you commit.

The model

This is a model, not a survey of real communities. The assumptions:

  • Every member pays $10/month. So 50 members bring in $500, 200 bring in $2,000, and 1,000 bring in $10,000.
  • Each platform’s cost is its entry monthly fee from our pricing data, plus its entry-plan sales fee as a percentage of that revenue.
  • Payment processor fees are excluded (Stripe, PayPal and the like). Every platform passes them on in some form, so they don’t change the ranking much, but your real bill is higher than these figures.
  • Only Bettermode prices by member count in our data ($149/mo up to 10,000 members). Every other tool is a flat fee at these sizes.

All platforms at 200 members ($2,000/month revenue)

RankPlatformMonthly feeSales feeMonthly costShare of revenue
1BuddyBoss$16.580%$16.580.8%
2Nas.com$20.750% on most sales$20.751.0%
3Mastermind.com$35not disclosed$351.8%
4Thinkific$360%$361.8%
5Graphy$370%$371.9%
6Whop$02.7%$542.7%
7Skool Pro$990%$995.0%
8Mighty Networks$792%$1196.0%
9Circle$892%$1296.5%
10Kajabi$1430%$1437.2%
11Memberful$494.9%$1477.3%
12Bettermode$1490%$1497.5%
12Heartbeat$495%$1497.5%
12Uscreen$495%$1497.5%
15Honeycommb$895%$1899.4%
16Patreon$010%$20010.0%
17Skool Hobby$910%$20910.4%
18Disciple$5050%$50525.2%
19Hivebrite$8951.5%$92546.2%

Skool appears twice because its two plans sit at opposite ends of the table. Discord is left out: the server is free, but it can’t take payments on its own, so its real cost is whatever paid tool you bolt on (Whop’s row is a fair stand-in).

A few rows need a caveat before you read too much into them:

  • BuddyBoss is a WordPress licence ($199/yr on renewal). You still pay for hosting and run the site yourself. That hosting cost isn’t in our data, so the $16.58 is a floor, not a total.
  • Nas.com lists a 0% platform fee on most sales, but 2.9% on digital products, plus payment processing. The model uses 0%. If your membership counts as a digital product, add 2.9%: $78.75 a month at 200 members, still 3.9% of revenue.
  • Mastermind.com doesn’t publicly disclose a sales fee. The model counts it as zero because there’s nothing to count.
  • Whop lists 2.7% + $0.30 per card sale with no monthly fee, and our record of it dates from June. Treat it as a listed rate.
  • Thinkific’s 0% applies with Thinkific Payments. Bring your own Stripe or PayPal on Basic and it adds 5%, which takes the 200-member cost to $136.
  • Uscreen’s $49 Starter plan is listed with a 100-subscriber cap, so a 200-member community would be on a higher plan with a per-subscriber charge. Treat its row as optimistic.
  • Patreon, Thinkific, Disciple and Honeycommb have no recent verification in our records. Their figures are listed prices, not re-checked ones. Disciple prices in GBP, so its dollar figure is approximate.

Who wins at each size

A percentage fee grows with you and a flat fee doesn’t, so the ranking moves a lot.

MembersRevenueCheapestNext threeMedian platform
50$500/moWhop, $13.50BuddyBoss $16.58, Nas.com $20.75, Mastermind.com $35$73.75 (14.8%)
200$2,000/moBuddyBoss, $16.58Nas.com $20.75, Mastermind.com $35, Thinkific $36$145 (7.2%)
1,000$10,000/moBuddyBoss, $16.58Nas.com $20.75, Mastermind.com $35, Thinkific $36$284 (2.8%)

At 50 members, Whop’s 2.7% is the cheapest option at $13.50. Skool Hobby costs $59: $40 a month less than Skool Pro, but already well above Nas.com’s flat $20.75. The enterprise platforms are absurd at this size: Disciple’s $505 fee is more than the $500 the community brings in, and Hivebrite would need about 91 members just to cover its own fee.

At 1,000 members, the 10% tools are the most expensive mainstream options in the data. Skool Hobby costs $1,009 a month and Patreon $1,000, which puts them level with Hivebrite ($1,045), a platform built for alumni networks and professional associations. Meanwhile Skool’s own Pro plan is still $99.

The middle of the market, Circle and Mighty Networks, sits between the two camps. Their 2% fee is small, but it still lifts them above Kajabi’s flat $143 once you pass 270 members (Circle) or 320 members (Mighty Networks). At 1,000 members, Circle costs about $3,468 a year against Kajabi’s $1,716.

The crossover: when a 10% fee stops making sense

On a $10 plan, a 10% fee costs you $1 per member per month. So the question is always: how many members until the cut adds up to more than a flat fee? Here are the break-even points the model gives, with each flat-fee option cheaper from the member count shown:

If you’re onSwitching toCheaper from
Skool Hobby ($9 + 10%)Nas.com ($20.75)12 members
Skool HobbyThinkific ($36)28 members
Skool HobbyHeartbeat ($49 + 5%)81 members
Skool HobbyMighty Networks ($79 + 2%)88 members
Skool HobbySkool Pro ($99)91 members
Skool HobbyCircle ($89 + 2%)101 members
Skool HobbyKajabi ($143)135 members
Patreon (10%)Nas.com ($20.75)21 members
PatreonThinkific ($36)37 members
PatreonSkool Pro ($99)100 members
PatreonCircle ($89 + 2%)112 members
Whop (2.7%)Nas.com ($20.75)77 members
WhopThinkific ($36)134 members
WhopSkool Pro ($99)367 members

The Skool line is the one most people should check. At exactly 90 members, Hobby and Pro cost the same ($99). Past that, every member on Hobby costs you an extra dollar a month. At 200 members, staying on Hobby costs $2,508 a year against $1,188 on Pro, so $1,320 a year goes to the fee, and upgrading would also get you Pro’s custom domain and affiliate program. At 1,000 members the gap is $10,920 a year.

And that understates it. Skool lists the Hobby fee as 10% plus $0.30 per sale. Our pricing data only counts the 10%. With the $0.30 added on 200 monthly payments, Hobby costs $269 a month, about 13% of revenue.

Patreon follows the same arithmetic. At 200 members, its roughly 10% cut costs $2,400 a year against $432 for Thinkific’s flat Basic plan. What Patreon offers instead is a brand fans already trust with their card, and no upfront cost while you find out if anyone will pay. That’s worth something early on. By 200 paying members it costs you $1,968 a year.

If you’re comparing Skool against Circle specifically, our Skool vs Circle page puts them side by side, and the longer Skool vs Circle vs Mighty Networks comparison covers what you get for the money beyond price.

What the numbers say to pick

  • Testing an idea with a few dozen members: Whop (2.7%) is the cheapest in the model until about 77 members. Skool Hobby ($9 + 10%) gives you a full community and course space, but pick it for the product, not the price: Nas.com’s flat $20.75 is cheaper from 12 members.
  • Past roughly 90-100 members: move to a flat fee. If you’re on Skool, that means Skool Pro. If you’re on Patreon, almost any flat-fee platform is cheaper by then.
  • Cheapest at any size from about 62 members: BuddyBoss, if you’re willing to run WordPress. Otherwise Nas.com ($20.75), Thinkific ($36) or Graphy ($37), all with a 0% platform fee on community sales in the model, are the cheapest hosted options in our data at 200 and 1,000 members.
  • A polished, dedicated community product: Circle (G2 4.8, the highest rating in this set) or Mighty Networks (4.4). Their 2% fee costs $40 a month at 200 members. That’s a fair price for the product, but know it’s there.
  • Disciple or Hivebrite: only if you need what they sell (Disciple’s fully branded app, Hivebrite’s alumni and association tooling). On price alone, neither makes sense for a $10 community under 1,000 members.

For the full ranking of community platforms on features as well as cost, see our best community platforms hub, or the best community platform for creators guide. If you sell courses or digital products alongside the community, creator platform transaction fees runs the same fee-versus-flat test across other categories.

Methodology

Fees come from the community section of TryToolFit’s pricing dataset: each platform’s entry plan (mostly at the annual-billing rate) and its entry-plan sales fee. Higher tiers on several platforms lower the fee (Circle Business 1%, Heartbeat Grow 2.5%), which the model doesn’t apply. Skool Pro is added from Skool’s tool record ($99, no platform fee) because it’s the obvious upgrade path. Monthly cost is fee + (sales fee × members × $10). Share of revenue is that cost divided by members × $10. Break-even member counts solve for where two cost lines meet and round up to the first whole member where the switch is cheaper. The median is across the 18 platforms in the dataset that can charge members directly (Discord excluded, Skool Pro not counted twice). Processing, taxes, self-hosting and add-ons are excluded. How we score tools is on our methodology page.

Run your own numbers

$10 a month is a round number, not a recommendation. At $30 a month every percentage fee triples in dollars and the crossovers arrive at a third of the member counts above. Plug your own price and member count into the pricing calculator, or answer a few questions in the advisor to get a shortlist matched to your size and budget.

Not sure which tool fits you?

Answer a few questions and the Advisor scores every tool against your needs in under a minute.

Get matched →

Keep reading

Get the creator-tool cheat sheet

One email: our current top pick in every category, plus the deals worth taking. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.